Otto Klemperer’s Long Journey Through His Times (1985)

Producer/Director/Screenwriter: Philo Bregstein

2784715.jpg

By Marilyn Ferdinand

Last night, in an act of pure kismet, I went in search of something to watch that wasn’t a feature film. I didn’t want to be bothered watching performances, analyzing dialogue, watching camerawork or set design. I just wanted to float through something that wasn’t so demanding on my analytical skills. Rather quickly, I laid hands on an old Facets video, a documentary about the great 20th century German conductor Otto Klemperer. The combination of cultural history and glorious music seemed ideal, so that’s what I watched.
As it happens, today is the anniversary of Klemperer’s birth, a fact I learned from Carl Grapentine, the morning host for WFMT, Chicago’s classical radio station. Klemperer (father of “Colonel Klink,” Werner Klemperer) would have been 124 years old, a number that shocked Grapentine as being too old for a conductor he witnessed in action. Klemperer lived to be 88, so just about any older adult who listened to classical music stood a chance of being able to see him conduct.

Klemperer’s long and tumultuous life threw a bit of a wrench into my plans for a leisurely evening in front of the TV screen. You just don’t loll around when a man talks about meeting Mahler and having him listening over his shoulder and correcting a score note written many years ago, discussing Jewish and Christian concepts of the divine with Sigmund Freud, or hanging out in Los Angeles with fellow refugees Igor Stravinsky, Arnold Schönberg, Bruno Walter, and Albert Einstein. I had to stop surfing around on my laptop and really pay attention—and I’m very glad I did.

67491-004-AD56C201.jpg

The documentary begins with Klemperer conducting under the opening credits and segues to the aged maestro rehearsing an orchestra. We will return to his rehearsals throughout this mainly chronological film, watching Klemperer’s seated form exert minimal movement to guide the musicians, sing measures of the score to show where he wants emphases to be, and scold one unfortunate violinist for not playing as instructed.

The story begins in Breslau, where Klemperer was born and given his first musical lessons by his mother, a talented pianist. He began his musical studies in Frankfort, though he wanted to become an actor. It was only when a theatrical production he was involved with lost its conductor that he was quickly seated at the podium. This, he said, thrilled him immensely—he just a music student and conducting an orchestra! This moment, I imagine, sealed his fate.

He went on to Berlin to continue his music education at the Stern Conservatory, where Hans Pfizner, a musician in the Romantic tradition, was his instructor. He mentions sitting in a park one day and watching a man walk slowly past. The man had a slight limp, and Klemperer realized that he was Gustav Mahler. I’m not certain how it happened, perhaps through Pfizner, but Klemperer and Mahler became acquainted. It was during this acquaintance that he received the score correction I mentioned earlier. Klemperer became enamored of modern music through Mahler’s influence, and it was Mahler whose recommendations secured Klemperer positions at the German National Theatre in Prague and in Hamburg. He continued to knock around Germany in the 1910s, accepting positions in Strausborg, Cologne, and Wiesbaden.

He conducted quite a bit of opera, thereby putting his actory ambitions into service in working with the production designers and singers on staging. His harsh musical opening and stark staging of Wagner’s The Flying Dutchman borrowed Berthold Brecht’s technique of epic alienation, angering conservative audiences, particularly the fledgling Nazis who favored heroic/romantic stagings of Wagner. His Fidelio removed the pleasantries of the traditional staging, putting the chorus of political prisoners in this, Beethoven’s only opera, in chains rather than allowing them to walk freely. Photos and music from these productions accompany this portion of the documentary’s exposition.

Igor Stravinsky, Eduard Dülberg, and Otto Klemperer at the world premiere of Oedipus Rex at the Kroll Opera, February 25, 1928

In 1927, Klemperer made his biggest mark, as music director of The Kroll Opera in Berlin, championing the modernist works of Mahler, Schönberg, Paul Hindemith, Stravinsky, and even Kurt Weill. The documentary gives us an excerpt of Klemperer conducting Weill’s Kleine Dreigroschenmusik (Suite from The Threepenny Opera).

Throughout this cinematic resume, Klemperer continuously comments on the social conditions around him, particularly the rise of the Nazis and the growing threat to the Jews of Europe. He remarks that after World War I, when Germans saw their troops come home spiffy and bedecked with flowers, it was hard to imagine they had actually lost the war; the blame was, “of course,” placed on the Jewish bankers. Klemperer had contact with some of the great thinkers of his day, including Marxist philosopher Ernst Bloch, whose musical content for The Spirit of Utopia (1918) he reviewed. When Klemperer, a Jew, learned that the Nazis had arrested a Jewish professor of his acquaintance (“Where is he?” “Nobody knows.”), he determined to leave Germany. He journeyed to Austria, Switzerland, France, and was invited to Los Angeles by a wealthy patron of the conductorless Los Angeles Philharmonic. In the film, he makes fun of the fat-cat society matrons who were his new masters; accounts of how he turned the ragtag musicians into a world-class orchestra show that the scorn was not mutual. And he agonized that all he could do was sit in exile while the Jews of Europe were being exterminated.

In 1939, a brain tumor left him semi-paralyzed and virtually unemployable. His career resurrection came as the chief conductor of the Budapest Opera (1947-1950). In 1959, he was appointed “principal conductor for life” of London’s Philharmonia Orchestra by its founder, Walter Legge. When Legge decided to disband the orchestra, it reorganized as the New Philharmonia under musician management, with Klemperer at its head.

conductors.jpg

Bruno Walter, Arturo Toscanini, Erich Kleiber, Otto Klemperer, and Wilhelm Furtwängler

Klemperer was devoted to the composer above all things and lived the philosophy of rehearse, rehearse, rehearse; he did something unheard of among penny-pinching opera companies—he rehearsed once with the orchestra alone and then with orchestra and singers. He studied scores as religious scholars study the Bible or the Koran; when he couldn’t get work conducting, this became his overriding preoccupation. Unlike the intensity of Toscanini or the romanticism of Furtwängler, he conducted without adding his own flourishes, and many of his recordings are considered authoritative—the “composer’s cut” if we put it in cinematic terms. His tempos tended to be slow (though I fancy nobody conducted a slower Mahler than Leonard Bernstein) and exact, which didn’t always please either his musicians or his audiences. Yet it’s very clear from this documentary that he was an emotional person who felt each note, and the excerpts to which we are treated sound just fine to my admittedly untrained ear. Among the musical excerpts in the film are the New Philharmonia playing Beethoven’s King Stephen Overture, Mozart’s Serenade KV 575, and Mahler’s Symphony No. 2 [Resurrection]; the Amsterdam Concertgebouw playing Schönberg’s Verklärte Nacht; footage of the Berlin Komische Oper’s production of Bizet’s Carmen; and the Berlin Staatskapelle performing the overture to Offenbach’s opera La Belle Hélène, as well as “Salome’s Dance” from Richard Strauss’s opera Salome.

Many of his professional collaborators were interviewed for this film, including conductor Paul Dessau, who worked under Klemperer at the Cologne Opera; Hans Curjel, who was Klemperer’s dramaturg at the Berlin Kroll Opera; Natalia Saz, a Russian theatre and opera director, whose good-hearted indifference to the male chauvinism of Western opera houses is delightfully expressed; and composer/conductor Pierre Boulez, who was flabbergasted that Klemperer wanted to watch him rehearse. Moje Forbach, the soprano who sang Senta in Klemperer’s production of The Flying Dutchman at the Kroll Opera gave insight into Klemperer’s matter-of-fact stage directions: “You will go here and then you Otto%201.jpgwill move here.” It was clear she was enchanted with Klemperer, testament perhaps to his reputation as a womanizer, a reputation that is not even alluded to here. Instead, we get the adoring reminiscences of his daughter Lotte, who also pays tribute to her mother, mezzo-soprano Johanna Klemperer. All agreed on Klemperer’s imposing height.

I commend Bregstein for digging up footage of some of Klemperer’s less accessible works, and think the use of photos interspersed with short talking-head interviews and voiceovers moved well. The sheer breadth of Klemperer’s life and career poses a challenge to anyone who wants to recount them, yet I didn’t feel overwhelmed by the material Bregstein presented. I think the documentary should have given some background on his recordings—one is left with the impression that when Klemperer couldn’t conduct, he wasn’t doing anything.

It may be hard to take in how revolutionary Klemperer really was in his time—shattering the Romantic movement with a headlong rush into modernism. But I know firsthand how difficult and contentious progress can be, especially in the classical music world. At a performance of Wagner’s (again!) Tannhäuser, I actually witnessed people booing, throwing programs, storming loudly out of the opera house. Why? Maverick director Peter Sellars had dared to stage it in modern dress as the story of disgraced televangelist Jimmy Swaggart. No play, film, or popular music concert I’ve witnessed has ever aroused such passions on a purely artistic basis. l

  • Sam Juliano spoke:
    16th/05/2009 to 10:01 am

    Ha Marilyn! I have seen the Ring Cycle in its entirety at the Metropolitan Opera House on three separate occasions over the years, and it’s always been the traditional transciption. But the Met is known for leaving Wagner be. Artistic director James Levine has fought for many years to maintain the work’s intrgrity. Likewise, the TANNHAUSER I saw there, like the PARSIFAL, DIE MEISTERSINGER and LOHENGRIN are similarly the orthodox interpretations. Sellars, of course is infamous, and I dare say his work has largely infuriated people far more than it’s ravished. The same controversy has surrounded the staging of Shakespeare for the past decades. I just saw a dire production this past Wednesday of THE MERCHANT OF VENICE at BAM, which completely altered the work’s essence, by updating the sets, despite maintaining the play’s myriad conflicts and themes.
    As far as Klemperer, I will say without reservation that he conducted the greatest ST. MATTHEW’S PASSION on record, showcasing the glorious voices of Fischer-Dieskau, Peter Pears, and Elizabeth Schwarzkoph to glorious effect, and bringing the work as close as a “religious experience” that has ever been performed since the earliest performance. His work on Bach’s other supreme masterpieces MASS IN B MINOR is also, perhaps, the most celebrated.
    You rightfully mention here (and even offer photos) of Klemperer’s work with Stravinsky, and later with Janacek, but he was always famed with his peerless guidance of Beethoven’s symphony cycle as well as Mahler’s, and there has surely NEVER been a greater transciption of the latter’s “Das Lied Von der Erde” with the gorgeous voices of Christina Ludwig and Fritz Wunderlich.
    God, what a great subject, and superb writing. I could go on and on…….
    I am a huge fan of Klemperer’s work Marilyn, and I own a number of his conducted operas. It’s true his work with Mahler is visionary

  • Marilyn spoke:
    16th/05/2009 to 10:24 am

    I was enthralled by Sellars’ Tannhauser. I love modern opera, and am debating whether to see Owen Wingrave this weekend (money, of course, is the issue) at Chicago Opera Theatre.
    It was hard to choose what from the film to offer. Of necessity, it skipped across his work, but the Kroll Opera and Mahler were featured prominently in the film.
    WFMT featured a lot of his Beethoven on his birthday, and all month they have been playing Fischer-Diskau as artist of the month (this is the anniversary of his 80th birthday). They played him singing some of Mahler’s song cycle works. Wonderful stuff.
    I’m so glad someone got something out of this review. I really was thrilled by the film, but it’s not readily available and I know classical music isn’t most people’s cuppa. If you’re interested in the film, I can run a DVD of it. I know Facets has forgotten it, and VHS tapes can run over $50 at the cheapest.
    Thanks, Sam, for sharing your thoughts. I loved them.

  • Sam Juliano spoke:
    16th/05/2009 to 1:21 pm

    Thanks very much Marilyn, I will go to netflix now and add it to the top of my queue.
    Marilyn, I do own the Margaret Williams-directed, Kurt Nagano-conducted film production of OWEN WINGRAVE on DVD, and it’s wonderful. (Owen is Gerald Finley and Specer Coyle is Peter Savidge) The film was shot entirely on location and is updated from Edwardian times to the 1950′s, establishing a coonection with World War II. While it doesn’t rank with PETER GRIMES, BILLY BUDD, nor A MIDSUMMER NIGHT’S DREAM among Britten’s operatic pantheon, nor with his haunting and sublime WAR REQUIEM, it’s certainly on the next level, methinks. That Chicago Lyric opera production sounds mighty fine!
    I can send a copy of this DVd on to you pronto.
    E Mail: TheFountain26@aol.com
    Yep, I never got over that Aronofsky film! LOL!

  • Janice Lemon spoke:
    1st/06/2009 to 9:18 pm

    I’d love to get hold of a copy of that documentary on Otto Klemperer. I first learned to love classical music (back more than 40 years ago now) by listening to Klemperer conducting all Beethoven’s symphonies. I remember reading somewhere (probably on the record sleeves of those long-gone days) that Klemperer hoped that his performance of conducting Bach’s Mass in Bminor “was adequate” as he did not like large unwieldy choirs.
    Whilst I have learnt to love other conductors (Furtwangler for one)probably Klemperer is my sentimental favourite. I owe to him my love of classical music.

  • Philo Bregstein spoke:
    9th/08/2009 to 3:56 pm

    Dear Marilyn Ferdinand
    Thank you so much for you beautifull review of my Klempererfilm that I found on the internet in an act of pure kismet, a you did find my film. I would like to tell you more about it . Please send me your emailadress.
    Best regards
    Philo Bregstein
    7 Rue Honoré Chevalier
    Paris 75006
    France

  • Douglas Pitre spoke:
    7th/06/2010 to 10:05 pm

    Please, please a DVD . My tape is unplayable. Of course referring to the Otto Klemperer’s Long Life…….
    I own about 180 dvds and 10 lps and 4 books ,etc re Klemperer.
    What music making.
    dwp

  • Douglas Pitre spoke:
    9th/06/2010 to 12:14 am

    Correction: 180 cds of Klemperer conducting. (not dvds)..sorry.
    Some performances dating to 1926. Friends you must hear, at least his, Mahler 2&4, Bruckner 4, Beethoveen 5,6,7,9, Brahams
    1,2, ANY Bach, Handel, Wagner, Operatic excerpts.
    The old school German conductors MUST be heard truly hear the truth in the masterpieces, namely Klemperer, Walter,Furtwangler,Abendroth, Knappertsbusch,Wand.

  • HERMAN SOENARIO spoke:
    20th/08/2011 to 12:34 am

    Many thanks for sharing the Klemperer documentary, and thanks to al those who reacted so positively. I heard Klemperer in a Beethoven Cycle in Amsterdam and in the Missa Solemnis with Schwarzkopf, Nan Merriman and Heinz Rehfuss. Wunderbar!
    The Missa I attended in AMsterdam, 17 May 1957 has recently appeard on Orchipel, sound is good for its age and very enjoyable (very special for me) CD available in England. a MUST HAVE!
    I would LOVE to obtain a DVD of the Klemperer doc? can anyone tell me how?
    Thanks from Australia

  • Jim Barr spoke:
    30th/11/2011 to 9:46 am

    I too have a lot of recordings of Klemperer, I agree with your other
    contributors, the St Matthew passion, in my opinion is the greatest recording ever, many years ago when radio 3 played his records of
    various works, compared to other recordings, by other conductors, I always thought now that sounds “RIGHT” maybe I’m on my own I don’t know, but to me so many orchestras playing the same works today seem to fast and lack dramatical expression. Jim Barr.

  • paul lewis spoke:
    10th/08/2012 to 6:50 pm

    I had no idea that this documentary film existed until I came upon it on You Tube. I was introduced to classical music by Klemperer’s recordings from the 60′s along with those by Solti, Karajan Kertesz etc. That seems like a golden age now with so many outstanding conductors around at that time. Klemperer remains for me one of the giants of the 20th c., his recording of Berlioz’s Symphonie Fantastique (Philharmonia orch) not a composer he is associated with, has in my opinion the finest lst and 2nd movements ever recorded, the tempo he adopts is perfect and makes all others sound rushed and lacking the extraordinary depth with which this score abounds.
    Of course his Beethoven 9th (live recording) remains the benchmark and perhaps allways will be.

  • Brian Pavier spoke:
    9th/05/2013 to 12:59 pm

    I know this question has been asked by others but is a DVD of Otto Klemperer’s Long Journey Through His Times (1985) any nearer?
    The tape is also very difficult to obtain.
    I salute a truly great Artist.

Leave your comment






(*)mandatory fields.

What others say about us

"You put a lot of love into your blog." – Roger Ebert, Roger Ebert's Journal
"Marilyn and Roderick … always raising the tone." – Farran Smith Nehme, The Self-Styled Siren
"Honestly, you both have made me aware of films I've never seen, from every era. Mega enriching." – Donna Hill, Strictly Vintage Hollywood
"You have my highest praise!" – Andreas, Pussy Goes Grrr




Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

Blogs

Chicago Resources

General Film Resources

Categories

Archives