The Red Balloon (Le Ballon Rouge, 1956)/White Mane (Crin-Blanc, 1953)

Director: Albert Lamorisse

White%20Mane%202.jpg

By Marilyn Ferdinand

We all tend to hold dear the images and experiences of our childhood. For people in their 20s, The Little Mermaid and Scooby Doo may be the beloved images of youth. For people who were young in the mid 1950s and early 1960s, The Red Balloon is sacred ground. The Red Balloon won just about every award for which it was eligible and played in movie theatres around the world. So popular was this magical story of a boy and his balloon that a chain of Red Balloon coffee houses opened. I remember driving past the restaurant with my parents and gazing fondly at the bronze, lifesize replica of the little boy at the top of a Parisian-style light pole reaching for the string of the painted-red balloon.

Like many of the other markers of my youth, the restaurant is gone, and the movie has faded from memory. But now in its 50th year of existence, Janus Films has begun touring The Red Balloon and White Mane, an earlier children’s film by the same director, on the arthouse circuit. The timing not only coincides with the Janus anniversary, but also capitalizes on the recent release of respected Chinese director Hou Hsiao-hsien’s The Flight of the Red Balloon. The childish thrill I experienced when I heard the song over the opening credits of The Red Balloon was an unexpected joy.

Balloon%202.jpgThe film opens with a gorgeous view of a neighborhood in a hilly part of Paris, its grey cobblestone streets and stairways ghostly in a morning mist. Then, our boy (Pascal Lamorisse, the director’s son) comes into the scene. The camera stays at his eye level as we watch him descend a few stairs and walk up a wall while holding onto a light pole. When he reaches the top, we see what he is after—a large, very round, red balloon. He has to grip the string in his mouth to descend the pole. Once safely on the ground, he grips the string and goes off to school.

The streetcar conductor won’t let him on with the balloon. Rather than let go, he runs all the way to school. He hurries through the door. A few moments later, he hurries back out. He finds an old man on the street and tells him to hold onto the balloon (“and don’t let go”) until he comes out. Miraculously, the man complies. When the boy gets home to his grandmother, we watch up at their apartment window as she opens the shutters and tosses the balloon out. But the balloon has picked the boy to be his friend, and it floats outside the window waiting for the boy to retrieve it.

The boy and the balloon are inseparable. It harasses a teacher who locks the boy up and follows a blue balloon a little girl is holding; the two balloons play and check each other out like a pair of pet dogs. It’s amazing how much personality an object can convey under the skillful direction of Lamorisse and the matter-of-fact acceptance of his son as the balloon’s friend. When the balloon finally is separated from the boy by an envious pack of boys from his school, all the balloons in Paris rush to his side to convey him to a place where he and the red balloon can be reunited. It’s a very special moment, and one of the most beautiful scenes ever captured on film.

White Mane is a new film to me, but this story of a wild and proud horse is a beautiful, somber, and sad affair that I would have loved as the dramatic, morbid child I was. (I asked my teacher to read Hans Christian Andersen’s “The Little Match Girl” to my second-grade class, and she was appalled by the death at the end.) Unfortunately, American parents of yesteryear pretended childhood was nothing but fun and games, and I doubt the film ever played in the States. To today’s parents who are overly paranoid about exposing their children to anything that might harm them—like reality—I issue the caution that this film is intense and violent.

White%20Mane%20lamorisse.jpgThe story takes place in the Camargue, a marshy region south of Arles in France known for its herd of small, wild horses. White Mane, the narrator (Peter Strauss) tells us, is the leader of his herd. He is sought by some gauchos who wish to tame him. They chase him over the dunes and lead him to a pen, where they try to break him. However, he escapes. They try again, setting fire to the marsh to flush him out, but he attacks their leader’s horse, which throws the man to the ground. “Whoever wants him can have him,” says the man in disgust. Young Folco (Alain Emery), a fisherman, overhears this remark and decides to make White Mane his. The horse takes a liking to him, and agrees to come back to his home, where Folco and his young brother (a very cute Pascal Lamorisse) live with their grandfather and a menagerie that includes one of the Camargue’s famed flamingos.

White Mane is happy with Folco, but when the gauchos drive his herd toward their ranch, he gives chase and ends up in a pen with another male from the wild herd that has taken his place as leader. He and White Mane fight for dominance of the herd. The battle of these two males is very intense, lengthy, and violent—nothing staged about it. White Mane is driven out and returns to Folco, who tends his wounds.

White%20Mane%201.jpg

Of course, the proud men are not about to give up so quickly. They decide to humble White Mane, but Folco takes off, riding him to the river. The two plunge into the water and are swept to sea, where the narrator relates that they are going to a place where men and horses live always as friends.

ballon_belleville3.jpgThe sad ending of White Mane rings true, coming from a man who had lived through the Nazi occupation of France and who made this film for children who had survived the war and were still dealing with its aftermath. The Red Balloon touches on the same theme by pitting envious, warring boys armed with slingshots against their smaller classmate and his defenseless, but brave, balloon. Although White Mane evokes the emotion of wartime Europe, reminders of the war are all around in the much more gentle The Red Balloon. Looking at the rubble the boy walks through, it’s not surprising that Lamorisse would want to evoke a bit of magic to take him away. In the end, the boy also leaves the world to go to a place where boys and their balloons can live unmolested. If you want to call these films a plea for peace—or even religious parables—you wouldn’t be far off. If you’re afraid your kids can’t handle them, ask them if they think life is just fun and games. They might surprise you. l

  • Emmay F. spoke:
    27th/11/2007 to 10:57 pm

    Hello there, I would like to thank you for this review on The “Red Balloon”- despite certain generational discepancies, this is a film that I remember from my childhood too.
    If I may pose a question: you make the statement,
    “He finds an old man on the street and tells him to hold onto the balloon (“and don’t let go”) until he comes out. Miraculously, the man complies.”
    Why is it miraculous?

  • Peter Nellhaus spoke:
    28th/11/2007 to 6:38 am

    I saw both films, separately, many years ago. To some extent I think The Red Balloon made me conscious of films beyond the Anglo-American stuff that comprised my earliest film going experience.

  • Marilyn spoke:
    28th/11/2007 to 8:44 am

    Emmay – Nice to see you! “Miraculous” in the sense that an adult 1) would do what a young boy would ask and 2) hold a balloon for the entire school day. Remember, we don’t know yet that the balloon will stay around without someone or something tethering it. It’s a lot to ask someone to do.
    Peter – I’m not sure I remembered that The Red Balloon was French when I was a child. Like the best children’s films (for example, Children of Heaven, dialogue isn’t really necessary to understand the film. I would certainly agree, though, that seeing something other than English-language films does open the door to understanding that there is a wide world of cinema out there. I was lucky to find that out on a regular basis by watching my local PBS station while growing up.

  • Kimberly spoke:
    7th/12/2007 to 1:03 pm

    I really love The Red Balloon. I first saw it at school. It was played one rainy afternoon by a teacher. This was in ’70s and the film deeply touched me and I never forgot it. I’ve never seen White Mane, but you’ve got me very curious about it. It sounds like a real tear jerker, but I sob like a baby when I watch The Red Balloon.

  • Marilyn spoke:
    7th/12/2007 to 3:41 pm

    I know what you mean, Kimberly. White Mane is a tough-minded movie. It’s sad, but I’m not sure I’d call it a tearjerker. White Mane and Folco are defiant. Live free or die is the motto of this movie.

  • Derek Potter spoke:
    16th/06/2008 to 9:16 am

    I can remember being taken to see this film by my school(perhaps about 1958) while I was about 12 years old. To be honest I don’t remember it having any particular effect on me at the time but, when I came across it recently, and viewed it I’m embarrassed to say the tears flowed. Whether this the effect of the film itself or the fact that I’m now reaching the autumn of my life and thinking about times past, and lost forever, I don’t know.

  • Marilyn spoke:
    16th/06/2008 to 10:53 am

    Derek – I’m a little past ripe myself and understand; I think it is films like this that help us appreciate the beauty of youth. Thanks for sharing that.

  • Larry spoke:
    15th/09/2008 to 11:55 am

    I just watched this film again on TCM and enjoyed it just as a kid. I see that you’re from Illinois. I grew up there, and remember going to the Red Balloon restaurant somewhere in the NW suburbs, with the little boy & balloon on the sign outside. Thanks for reminding me!

  • Marilyn spoke:
    15th/09/2008 to 12:03 pm

    Yes, that’s it! The Northwest suburbs is the one we went to.

  • David Hughes spoke:
    12th/12/2008 to 4:21 pm

    I thought I was the only person in the universe who had seen this film as a child. What a delight to know we share this marvel, compared to future upcomings who can revel in the delights that they both watched one of those american high school films! Film Directors should do more homework and look at some of these classic films and realise box office is not what makes you!!

  • Marilyn spoke:
    12th/12/2008 to 8:15 pm

    I couldn’t agree more, David. I was so pleased that this made the rounds again for another generation of children. I really hope a lot of adults like you and me took them to see it. Thanks for stopping by.

  • Nick tarling spoke:
    27th/12/2010 to 2:56 pm

    growing up in the 1960s I would see this film in my summer holidays on TV.

    The film is a treasure, one of the great pieces of celluloid artwork at nearly 60 years old this simple story so well filmed in a simpler time that seems so distant to us now, and it still has the power to affect the emotions in so many ways.

    For me the film stands way above any big buck hollywood blockbuster. PS watch “the man who planted trees”

Leave your comment






(*)mandatory fields.

What others say about us

"You put a lot of love into your blog." – Roger Ebert, Roger Ebert's Journal
"Marilyn and Roderick … always raising the tone." – Farran Smith Nehme, The Self-Styled Siren
"Honestly, you both have made me aware of films I've never seen, from every era. Mega enriching." – Donna Hill, Strictly Vintage Hollywood




Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

Blogs

Chicago Resources

General Film Resources

Categories

Archives