Exotica (1994)

Director: Atom Egoyan

mia-exotica05.jpg

By Marilyn Ferdinand

Everybody knows that you’re in trouble/
Everybody knows what you’ve been through/
From the bloody cross on top of calvary/
To the beach of Malibu/
Everybody knows it’s coming apart/
Take one last look at this sacred heart/
Before it blows/
And everybody knows.
—”Everybody Knows” by Leonard Cohen

Grief is an emotion that many people find unbearable—unbearable to feel and unbearable to observe. Atom Egoyan, a Canadian director of Armenian ancestry, has an ethnic heritage of grief over the slaughter of 1 million of his Armenian brethren by their Turkish conquerors that seems to have informed his film explorations. The Sweet Hereafter and Ararat deal indirectly and directly with tragedy and its attendant guilt. Similarly, Exotica explores the amorphous boundaries of grief, weaving a web of connections and disconnections that brings its main characters face to face with their own illusions.

The film opens on an illusion—a two-way mirror through which customs guards observe passengers at Toronto’s airport and the guards who go through their bags. One passenger, Thomas (Don McKellar), moves directly to the mirror, seeming to examine himself, but perhaps aware that he is being examined. A customs officer being coached in how to observe (Calvin Green) moves forward, coming nearly nose to nose with Thomas, prevented from touching him only by the trick pane of glass. This motif of illusion, concealment, and barriers will play itself out not only in Thomas’ story, but also in the film’s central story.

That story’s crucible is Exotica—a gentleman’s club that trafficks in fantasy. Exotic dancers perform various types of fantasies for the audience, and for just $5 more, they will bring those fantasies to the privacy of a client’s table. Christina (Mia Kirshner), a dark-haired young woman who dances in schoolgirl clothes to Leonard Cohen’s “Everybody Knows” is the particular favorite of Francis (Bruce Greenwood), who comes to the club every other night and pays to have her dance at his table or just talk. The two are watched jealously by Eric (Elias Koteas), the club’s DJ/MC and Christina’s ex-lover. Artificial caverns run behind the client booths with two-way mirrors that Zoe (Arsinée Khanjian), the club’s owner, uses to watch for inappropriate behavior, specifically clients who touch the dancers. Eric frequently sits behind Francis’ table when Christina is there, watching and seething at their special relationship.

up-6exotica1.gifThrough the use of flashback, we learn that Francis has suffered a tragic loss. His beloved daughter was murdered, and his wife died in a car crash a few weeks later, a possible suicide. Francis was implicated in the murder, but never charged. He keeps his grief in check by carrying on an illusion of normalcy. On the nights he goes to Exotica, he brings Tracey (Sarah Polley), his daughter’s babysitter, to his house where she practices on his piano, then brings her home and pays her. Tracey, disturbed by this arrangement, asks her father (Victor Garber), an old friend of Francis’, if she can stop going. “There’s no baby to sit.”

Exotica%2010.JPG Christina, Eric, and Francis have a creepy connection as well. Eric and Christina met while on the massive search for Francis’ daughter. Christina, too, babysat for his daughter and gained consolation from him for the lack of warmth shown her by her own family. There can be no doubt that Eric finds this eroticized father-daughter type of relationship unhealthy, possibly dangerous, and this feeling and his own jealousy cause him to drive a wedge between the pair.

Thomas enters this web when Francis comes to audit the records of his pet shop and blackmails him into trying to mend the rift with Christina and the Exotica management. Thomas, it seems, has been smuggling the eggs of exotic species of birds into the country. A method he stumbled upon to pick up men snags him, unwittingly, the customs guard who observed him so closely at the airport. After a night of sex, Thomas awakens to find the eggs have vanished.

Exotica weaves coincidence into meaning, reality into illusion and back to reality again. We become aware of the hurts each character in this film has suffered, but we also learn that we can’t trust anyone too far. Eric loves Christina, but he destroys a relationship that was special to her and then seems to take her place as Francis’ consoler. Thomas rejects one man who might have been good for him, but invites the wrong one home. And then there is Francis himself. He doesn’t seem as though he could harm his daughter, but his wife’s suspicious death and his visits to the Exotica cause us to wonder more than we should. Egoyan not only has dealt with dead children before, but also incest.

Exotica is an elliptical, but nonetheless, schematic film that some may not find satisfying. I like the atmosphere it creates; the suggestion that we can find what we need, at least for a time; and its linking of sex with death. These potentially dark elements of human experience carry a charge that many filmmakers have explored, but I can think of few who have done so with such sympathy, lack of judgment, and intrigue. l

  • SeaNymphette spoke:
    15th/09/2007 to 7:19 am

    If you listen closely to the dialog, it intimates that the character played by Victor Garber, the character that is Tracey’s father, is not Francis’ old friend, but Francis’ brother. Francis’ brother was having an affair with Francis’ wife and in the vehicle with her, when she was killed. That is why he is in a wheelchair. One of the reasons that I really liked this film is that it didn’t make a big social issue of Francis’ interracial marriage, and biracial daughter. The film presented them as an average family who just happened to be of multiple races, which is very similar to my own family. A lot of people I talk to about this film don’t seem to get the sequencing with the flashbacks, but people nowadays rarely get things that they actually have to patiently pay attention to. I get the connection between sex and death where Francis’ wife was concerned, but I didn’t get the sexualization of his dead daughter through Christina. Francis just didn’t strike me as incestuous or pedophilic (or even sexually interested in Christina, he just seems to want to get comfort from her and be reminded of his daughter), so Cristina’s costume was disturbing to me. It reminded me of Japanese films and Anime. I noticed that many Japanese films have stock female characters dressed in schoolgirl costumes. What that says about the predilection of Japanese men, since it is primarily men making these films and animations, is scary. Anyhow, what I took from this film is that the three main characters Francis, Eric, and Christina were tied together by a devastating tragedy (you’ll remember that Eric and Christina were the two in the search party who discovered Francis’ daughter’s discarded corpse), and the fallout from that tragedy was that it changed all of their lives profoundly, and not necessarily for the better. Christina and Francis discovered that they can help each other. Christina helps Francis by reminding him of his daughter. Francis helps Christina by being a man that she can still actually feel compassion for (being a stripper seems to have desensitized Christina to men and completely numbed her, as indicated by her icy treatment of Eric). There arrangement isn’t healthy but serves it’s purpose until Eric ruins it. I like the way it comes around in the end. I didn’t think the story with Thomas and the Customs Agent was even necessary to the film, sort of like a side story.

Leave your comment






(*)mandatory fields.

What others say about us

"You put a lot of love into your blog." – Roger Ebert, Roger Ebert's Journal
"Marilyn and Roderick … always raising the tone." – Farran Smith Nehme, The Self-Styled Siren
"Honestly, you both have made me aware of films I've never seen, from every era. Mega enriching." – Donna Hill, Strictly Vintage Hollywood
"You have my highest praise!" – Andreas, Pussy Goes Grrr




Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

Blogs

Chicago Resources

General Film Resources

Categories

Archives